MAT336: History of Mathematics
Fall 2025
Presentation Guidelines and Grading Rubric
About the Topic
- You do not need to cover your entire assigned topic. Choose a part that you can explain clearly, including both mathematics and history.
- What you explain doesn’t have to be hard—but it should be something you understand deeply. This means choosing something you worked to understand, not something you already knew.
- If you talk about applications, they must relate to the historical development of the idea. (For example, you can explain how the idea of the normal distribution emerged, but not how it’s used today.)
About the Presentation
- Important:You may break the rules on this page to make a better presentation—but only if you talk to me first, explain your reasons, and I give you explicit approval.
- Your presentation should be 8-10 minutes long.
- Your goal is to teach your classmates something.
- This presentation should cover the same topic as your final paper.
- Remember to follow the course AI policy when researching your topic.
- Public speaking can be scary, but we will be a supportive audience.
- Using notes is fine, but don't just read from them.
- You may include an activity or handout—ask me first if you need extra time.
- There will be 2-3 minutes for questions at the end. It's okay if you don't know an answer right away; you can follow up the next week.
Grading Rubric
Criteria |
Excellent (Full) |
Good (Partial) |
Needs Improvement |
Not Demonstrated |
Points |
Mathematical Content |
Deep understanding; a nontrivial example is clearly explained step by step |
Mostly clear, with minor gaps |
Unclear or shallow explanation |
Concept misunderstood or missing |
/30 |
Historical Content |
Deep, accurate, and well-integrated |
Accurate, but could be more fully developed |
Basic coverage, lacks depth |
Inaccurate or missing |
/30 |
Teaching Clarity |
Clear teaching goal, good pacing, and actively engages the audience |
Mostly clear; some engagement; minor issues with pacing or structure |
Unfocused or hard to follow; little audience awareness |
No clear goal or effort to connect with audience |
/15 |
Delivery & Language |
Confident, accessible; not reading from slides; presentation is 8–10 minutes |
Some reading; mostly clear language; slightly over/under time |
Heavy reading or jargon; significantly too short or too long |
Mumbled, read-only, unclear language; far off from time requirement |
/10 |
Creativity |
Original approach; personal perspective; non-standard but effective structure or style |
Some originality or unique elements |
Few original ideas; mostly standard format |
No creative effort; generic presentation |
/5 |
Notes
- Practice your presentation: Rehearse out loud - with a friend, in front of a mirror, or even just talking to yourself. This helps you identify what works, what needs adjustment, and builds your confidence.
- You can also schedule a rehearsal with me (in person or via Zoom). Just email me with 3 or 4 possible time slots, or come to office hours.
-
Trivial example: Simply stating a formula or definition.
Nontrivial example: Showing how a concept works—through a calculation, proof, or worked example that demonstrates real understanding.
- A strong example presentation is available for reference. Note: it is longer than what’s required for this course.